Showing posts with label Social hierarchy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Social hierarchy. Show all posts

Monday, April 27, 2015

Downton Abbey, Season 2 Episode 8 (25:39-27:10)


Title: Downton Abbey, Season 2 Episode 8 (25:39-27:10)
Tags: Power Elites, Power Positions, Social hierarchy, Social norms, social structure, Access to power, 
Author: T. Stachowiak
Date: April 27th, 2015



Downton Abbey:
The PBS and BBC Masterpiece drama, Downton Abbey, focuses on the Crawley family and residents of the household during 1912-1924. It is a perfect example of Mills classical power display, focusing on how the aristocracy and the household staff interact. Focusing on Mills’ Theory of Balance and how the characters uphold and challenge their society’s social structures. “It is very difficult to give up the old model of power as an automatic balance, with its assumptions of a plurality of independent, relatively equal, and conflicting groups of the balancing society.” (p.234) Thus, we can see Mills’ theories enacted in which all social classes work to maintain the norm. Mills’ theory of balance includes Tom Branson, a chauffeur, and Lady Sybil, daughter of Lord Grantham. They, unlike Carson, challenge the balance because they fall in love and want to be married. They try to change the minds of the aristocracy, however Lord Grantham greatly opposes because he thinks he knows what is best for Sybil. In his efforts to stop the marriage he tries to pay off Tom so he will leave the family alone. Tom doesn’t take the money and he states that he will not take the money because not everyone can be paid off like ‘people of his kind’ think is possible for every situation. This statement also shows that Branson tries to show that he deserves social power although he is 'under' Lord Grantham. This scene also displays the transition of power happening during the time. 

Sunday, April 26, 2015

Downton Abbey, Season 1, Episode 7 (17.05-17.20 and 41.35-42.10)


Title: Downton Abbey, Season 1, Episode 7 (17.05-17.20 and 41.35-42.10)
Tags: social hierarchy, social movement, social norms, technological advance 
Author: S. Webber
Date: April 26, 2015 



A period piece spanning from 1912-1924 produced by PBS and BBC Masterpiece Drama, Downton Abbey follows the everyday occurrences and struggles of the individuals of the estate. This includes the Crawley family, the owners, and a predominant selection of their household servants. This household provides excellent displays of C. Wright Mills’ theories from The Power Elite, regarding traditional power dynamics. The power elite, to which the Crawleys belong, determine the existence of everyday life and the social mobility curtailed to those not born into the correct class. The show illustrates the precarious walk the Crawleys perform in efforts to maintain their status and estate during changing social times. The inevitable advance of technology serves throughout the show as a metaphor for the collapse of the known social hierarchy, and exemplifies Mills’ theory of balance in this particular episode. Mills’ theory demands that all members of society uphold the social norms, regardless of how they fail to serve the majority in the long run. This is done simultaneously to hold onto what small power they may have amassed and because challenging power balances is unbelievably difficult (p. 234). The head butler, Carson, provides this example in his resistance to adapt the telephone into the household, illustrating his maintenance of tradition. Later, he falsely claims he knows how to work it when asked by lower servants- done so to preserve his status as head of the house ‘below the stairs.’